5 min read

Creating Psychological Safety: The Key to High-Performing Teams

Kim Scott’s feedback epiphany shows how honest care nurtures fearless dialogue, accelerating innovation and productivity through psychological safety for teams.
Creating Psychological Safety: The Key to High-Performing Teams
A.I. Generated

👋🏻 Hello growth seekers,

Kim Malone Scott still remembers the drone of fluorescent lights in a Google hallway when Sheryl Sandberg stopped her for “a quick word.” Their AdSense unit had just shattered every goal, so Kim expected congratulations. Sandberg did congratulate her—then, in the same breath, pointed out that Kim’s habit of saying “um” during briefings was eroding her authority and offered to connect her with a speech coach. The feedback landed like cold water, yet the calm respect behind it made the critique feel like fuel rather than a rebuke. In that instant Kim saw a deeper truth: if performance reviews felt like surprise attacks, people would spend their energy shielding egos instead of solving problems; but if honesty arrived wrapped in genuine care, teams could trade self-protection for creativity. From that day forward she treated candour and kindness as twin rails of the same track. Drawing on research showing that adults think best when mistakes don’t threaten belonging, Kim swapped annual post-mortems for quick, honest check-ins. The result was more than higher morale; it was sharper problem-solving, faster learning, and a culture where no one wasted energy protecting pride.

💡 Turning Candor into Daily Practice

To make candour the norm, Kim adopted two deceptively simple questions: “What’s getting in your way?” and “How can I help?” The first encouraged people to name obstacles without fear of blame, keeping the brain in learning rather than threat mode. The second signalled partnership, not rescue, reinforcing each person’s agency. Over a few months these micro-rituals rewired team habits. Engineers surfaced half-formed concepts, marketers flagged risky assumptions sooner, and the once-quiet intern felt safe challenging a director’s slide. Quantitative gains followed: bug-fix cycles shortened by a third, client satisfaction climbed, and voluntary turnover approached zero. Yet the richer story lay in what spreadsheets missed. Conversations that once happened in hushed side channels moved into daylight; late-night prototypes were punctuated by laughter; feedback flowed sideways, not only downward. Neuroscience tells us safety and stretch aren’t a trade-off but a tandem drive system—when people trust the group, they take bigger intellectual risks. Kim’s meetings became living proof. By making it emotionally affordable to speak up, she freed mental bandwidth once spent on impression management. Innovation, rather than hierarchy, began setting the tempo.

🚀 Building Your Own Safe Zone
None of this requires Silicon Valley budgets—only consistency. Start your next team huddle by spotlighting the boldest question asked last week; you teach everyone that curiosity outranks certainty. Schedule a monthly “rookie review” where the newest colleague inspects a legacy process and tells the veterans what looks odd; fresh eyes locate friction faster than status-quo owners ever can. Try a 90-second closing round in which each participant names one thing they would do differently if they led the project—and let leaders go first. By inviting critique of your own work before anyone else’s, you lower the social cost of honesty across the board. Follow through, visibly, on at least one suggestion each cycle; nothing signals safety louder than action. If you manage remotely, replace hallway chats with brief video check-ins that begin with the same two questions Kim used. Over time these rituals let people feel accepted first and evaluated second, exactly how adults learn best. Mistakes become data points, not identity threats. That frees cognitive capacity for harder tasks—innovating, pattern-spotting, anticipating customer needs. With gossip energy drained from the room, momentum flows toward the work itself. Psychological safety may sound soft, but the business payoff is anything but: lower attrition, faster cycle times, and a team ready to tackle problems you haven’t even imagined yet. Give your people that foundation and watch how high they’ll climb.

Practical tools

Offer practical insights, tips, or strategies related to personal leadership development and growth. Provide bite-sized, actionable advice that readers can implement. Use one emoticon per paragraph. Must be related to the leading story

💬 Feedback Mirrors Session
Once a month, block 90 minutes for a “mirrors” meeting where one project is placed in the center and the team circles it with observations—not judgments. The presenter speaks last, listening first as colleagues reflect on what’s working, what feels rough, and where they saw genuine spark. Because the critique lands on the work, not the person, psychological safety climbs while blind spots shrink. Leaders reinforce the norm by thanking the toughest insight, then sharing the single improvement they plan to pilot before the next sprint.

🔍 Rookie-Lens Rotation
Fresh eyes see the dust long-timers ignore. Give the newest member ownership of a legacy process for one week—documentation, metrics, and all. Their brief to the group at Friday’s stand-up often reveals outdated steps, hidden costs, or customer friction no dashboard flags. When veterans respond with curiosity rather than defense, the unwritten rule becomes clear: tenure earns listening, not immunity. Turnover drops because newcomers feel heard from day one; productivity rises because the process gets lighter every cycle.

🚦 Signal-and-Sandbox Protocol
Adopt a traffic-light check-in at the start of every project review: green (all clear), amber (risk brewing), red (help needed). No explanations yet—just the color. Ambers and reds automatically earn a protected “sandbox” slot on the agenda where the issue can be explored without blame or premature fixes. The ritual normalizes risk-talk, speeds resource allocation, and shuts down firefighting theatrics. Over time, teams report problems when they’re small and solvable, not headline-worthy.

🛠️ Leader Vulnerability Sprint Twice a year, managers publish a personal performance goal—perhaps tighter storytelling or sharper financial modeling—and invite the team to coach them. Progress updates go into the same dashboard as product KPIs, signalling that growth is everyone’s job. When authority figures model unfinished skills, permission to experiment cascades downward. The payoff: employees spend less energy guarding reputation and more on bold initiatives, driving a virtuous loop of learning and output. 

Food For Thought

Welcome to the "Food for Thought" section, your gateway to a curated selection of resources that will nourish your curiosity and inspire your creative journey. In this corner of Growth Republic, we bring a collection of insightful resources that you can look for on the web, from thought-provoking podcasts or books, to illuminating online articles that can expand your horizons and deepen your understanding of the topics we explore. Consider it your intellectual pantry, stocked with ingredients to feed your mind, and ignite your creativity. Dive into these resources and let the feast of knowledge begin.

📖 Book: Radical Candor — Kim Scott’s modern classic unpacks how pairing direct challenge with deep personal care fuels psychological safety and outsized results. 

📘 Book: The Fearless Organization — Harvard professor Amy Edmondson distills two decades of research showing why safe-to-speak-up cultures innovate faster and bounce back from error. 

📗 Book: Humble Inquiry — Edgar Schein offers practical dialogue techniques for leaders who want questions, not directives, to spark employee insight and commitment. 

🎙️ Podcast: WorkLife with Adam Grant—“Is It Safe to Speak Up at Work?” — Organizational psychologist Adam Grant explores the mechanics of voice, error prevention, and inclusive innovation with guests from aviation to academia.

Quote Of The Week
«Leadership is communicating to people their worth and potential so clearly that they are inspired to see it in themselves.»
- L. David Marquet

About the Author

Hi, I am Cesare Zavalloni. I am a Certified Executive Coach by IMD business school and Associated Certified Coach (ACC), member of International Coaching Federation (ICF). I bring more than 20+ years of experience as corporate executive in Fortune 100 companies and as outdoor adventurer. My purpose is to guide, encourage and inspire young professionals and executives like you to see your authentic leadership nature and the new possibilities this realization creates.

Enjoy this newsletter?

Forward to a friend, sharing is caring.

Was this forwarded to you? If you would like to receive it in the future, subscribe here.

Anything else? Hit reply to send us feedback or say hello. We don't bite!

Here's to a future of growth and success!

© 2023 LEADERFULLY Sàrl - CHE-425.245.494 - Privacy Policy - Cookie Policy - Credits